Why Rays’ Ryan Pepiot Is a Sleeper Arm to Back This Week

The Tampa Bay Rays are quietly putting together one of the more intriguing pitching developments of the 2025 season—Ryan Pepiot. Once a high-variance starter with flashes of brilliance and bouts of inconsistency, Pepiot is now emerging as a legitimate rotation asset. With tough upcoming matchups against Houston’s Framber Valdez and Toronto’s Chris Bassitt, it’s a make-or-break stretch.

While the average bettor might shy away, there’s an opportunity here for those willing to dig deeper. Pepiot’s advanced metrics and recent form suggest he could be a profitable contrarian play.

Swing for the Fences with SportsGrid’s free daily MLB Game Picks and MLB Prop Picks.

Ryan Pepiot: Trending Up and Under the Radar

Pepiot’s early-season struggles caused concern, but over his last five starts, he’s been far more effective:

• 3.18 ERA

• 21 strikeouts to 8 walks

• Improved command and efficiency with his changeup and slider

• Increased usage of high-locating fastballs generating weak contact

Pitching analyst Eno Sarris was high on Pepiot entering 2025, citing his pitch mix and breakout potential—and those predictions are starting to pan out.

Fantasy & Betting Insight:

• In daily fantasy, Pepiot offers upside at a discount in GPPs

• In betting markets, he presents value as an underdog or in first-five inning bets, especially when facing weakened offenses

Assessing Clayton Kershaw’s Value in Fantasy Baseball

Next Starts: Tough on Paper, Not Impossible in Practice

1. Houston Astros (Framber Valdez Matchup)

• Yes, Framber is a solid lefty, but Houston’s lineup has been underwhelming:

  • No Yordan Alvarez

  • Jose Altuve aging and inconsistent

  • Christian Walker still slumping, failing to string together productive ABs

This is not the fearsome Astros offense of years past. Pepiot can survive, especially if the Rays get a few early runs on the board.

2. Toronto Blue Jays (Chris Bassitt Matchup)

• Bassitt’s command has been shaky, and the Blue Jays have struggled with strikeout-prone approaches vs. righties

• Tampa’s offense is opportunistic—they feast on mistakes, and Pepiot’s pitch mix could neutralize Toronto’s boom-or-bust core

Betting Angle: Consider Rays ML or F5 +0.5 in both starts. Even as slight underdogs, they could be a sharp value play in series where public money leans toward better-known arms.

2025 Fantasy Baseball: Should You Buy Low on Bryan Reynolds?

Prospect Watch: Ian Seymour Could Shake Things Up

While Pepiot is starting to shine, the Rays’ pitching factory never sleeps. Keep an eye on Ian Seymour, who is leading Triple-A in strikeouts and drawing attention within the organization.

If Seymour is called up, it could give Tampa another weapon for:

• Back-end rotation depth

• Spot starts in tough AL East matchups

• Betting edge in lesser-known debut matchups where oddsmakers underprice talent

Dynasty and DFS managers should take note—Seymour could be a difference-maker before the All-Star break.

Pitching Analysis: Pirates vs. Phillies at Citizens Bank Park

Rays Betting Strategy Moving Forward

1. Back the Rays in Underdog Spots with Pepiot

• Especially at home or when facing teams with key offensive injuries

• Great First 5 underdog value, particularly in pitcher-friendly matchups

2. Monitor Run Line +1.5 Opportunities

• Tampa often plays tight, low-scoring games when Pepiot pitches

• Backing the Rays +1.5 at even money or better has solid ROI potential

3. Watch for Team Total Overs

• Opponents often overlook the Rays’ offense; with Pepiot keeping them in games, their bats have more chances to win late

Final Thoughts: Buy In on Pepiot Before the Market Does

Ryan Pepiot isn’t just holding down a rotation spot—he’s quietly improving every week. His underlying metrics are stabilizing, and with Houston and Toronto both looking vulnerable, this is the time to invest.

Fantasy players, don’t hesitate to ride his two-start week. Bettors, look for edge spots where the books overvalue name-brand opponents and overlook the matchup details.

Stay ahead of the game and elevate your sports betting experience with SportsGrid.