Sportsgrid-Staff

Predicting MLB Comeback Player of the Year: Key Insights

MLB Awards futures present an excellent opportunity for bettors to find value and capitalize on player narratives. The AL Comeback Player of the Year award is one of the most intriguing betting markets, with several star players vying for recognition. This season, three names stand out in the race: <a href="https://www.sportsgrid.com/mlb/players/shane-mcclanahan/57871">Shane McClanahan</a>, <a href="https://www.sportsgrid.com/mlb/players/jacob-degrom/57655">Jacob deGrom</a>, and <a href="https://www.sportsgrid.com/mlb/players/michael-trout/57605">Mike Trout</a>. Each brings a unique storyline and potential betting value. Let&#8217;s break down the odds, expectations, and best wagers for the award.
Swing for the Fences with SportsGrid’s free daily<a href="https://www.sportsgrid.com/mlb/picks"> MLB Game Picks</a> and <a href="https://www.sportsgrid.com/mlb/player-props">MLB Prop Picks</a>.
<h3>Shane McClanahan: The Safe but Strong Pick</h3>
Tampa Bay Rays&#8217; ace Shane McClanahan is a top contender for the award, and for good reason. His return from Tommy John surgery positions him as a player with a high ceiling. Unlike <a href="https://www.sportsgrid.com/mlb/players/sandy-alcantara/58308">Sandy Alcántara</a>, who pitched the entire 2023 season, McClanahan only managed 21 starts before injury shut him down. This extra recovery time makes him a more intriguing bounce-back candidate.
Another key factor is Tampa Bay’s six-man rotation, which gives McClanahan additional rest between starts. Plus, with <a href="https://www.sportsgrid.com/mlb/players/peter-fairbanks/57866">Pete Fairbanks</a> anchoring the bullpen, the Rays have strong &#8220;win equity"—meaning McClanahan doesn’t need to go deep into games to rack up victories. His current odds sit at +350, a solid value bet that could pay off if he stays healthy.
Ranking MLB Starting Rotations: <a href="https://www.sportsgrid.com/mlb/article/ranking-the-al-east-starting-rotations-for-the-2025-mlb-season">AL East</a> | <a href="https://www.sportsgrid.com/mlb/article/ranking-the-al-central-starting-rotations-for-the-2025-mlb-season"> AL Central</a> | <a href="https://www.sportsgrid.com/mlb/article/ranking-the-al-west-starting-rotations-for-the-2025-mlb-season">AL West</a> |
<h3>Jacob deGrom: A High-Risk, High-Reward Option</h3>
Few pitchers have dominated baseball like Jacob deGrom did in his prime. However, injuries have kept him out of the spotlight for much of the last few seasons. Now with the Texas Rangers, deGrom has the opportunity to lead the rotation following the departure of <a href="https://www.sportsgrid.com/mlb/players/maxwell-scherzer/57669">Max Scherzer</a>.
His odds to win AL Comeback Player of the Year are around +400, which offers a tempting payout. The biggest concern? Durability. The Rangers need him to be the ace again, but after a long injury history, can he return to Cy Young form? The public recognition and narrative factor work in his favor, making him a strong speculative play for bettors looking to take a chance on a big comeback story.
MLB Free Agency:
<a href="https://www.sportsgrid.com/mlb/article/ranking-the-top-10-remaining-mlb-free-agents">Ranking the Top 10 Remaining MLB Free Agents</a>
<a href="https://www.sportsgrid.com/mlb/article/predicting-landing-spots-for-the-top-10-players-available-in-mlb-free-agency">Predicting Landing Spots for the Top 10 Players Available in MLB Free Agency</a>
<h3>Mike Trout: The Tempting but Risky Bet</h3>
When it comes to name recognition, few in baseball rival Mike Trout. The three-time AL MVP has battled injuries in recent years, making him a prime candidate for a comeback. But there&#8217;s a major caveat: health concerns.
With the Angels adding power hitter <a href="https://www.sportsgrid.com/mlb/players/jorge-soler/58511">Jorge Soler</a> behind him, Trout could benefit from more lineup protection. If he stays in the No. 2 or No. 3 spot, he will get plenty of RBI opportunities. However, the biggest red flag remains the number of games he can stay on the field. At +500 odds, Trout is a high-risk, high-reward option. If you’re willing to take the gamble, the payout could be massive.
<h3>Best Bet for AL Comeback Player of the Year</h3>
Given the factors at play, McClanahan and deGrom offer the best betting value. If you prefer a safer, more strategic bet, McClanahan at +350 is a smart pick due to his team’s structure and &#8220;win equity." If you want a bigger payout with more risk, deGrom at +400 is an intriguing play given his history as one of baseball’s best pitchers.
<a href="https://www.sportsgrid.com/newsletter/?utm_source=msn_feed&amp;utm_medium=video&amp;utm_campaign=newsletter">Have all the intel you need? Free actionable info is one click away! Sign up for our daily newsletter.</a>
<h3>Final Betting Strategy: Shop the Odds</h3>
Odds for these players will fluctuate throughout the season. Savvy bettors should compare odds across multiple sportsbooks and look for opportunities to hedge bets as the season unfolds. AL Comeback Player of the Year is a media-driven award, meaning the narrative around these players will shift with performance and public perception. Keeping an eye on health updates and player performance trends will help maximize potential payouts.
Where would you place your early wager? McClanahan’s steady outlook or deGrom’s comeback storyline? Either way, the AL Comeback Player of the Year race is shaping up to be an exciting market for MLB bettors.
Stay ahead of the game and elevate your sports betting experience with<a href="https://www.sportsgrid.com/"> SportsGrid</a>.

MLB AL Comeback Player of the Year: Futures Betting Guide

With Roon on the mound, the Yankees are now big favorites against the Red Sox, with odds jumping from -200 to -230. The game's total is set at 8 runs.

Yankees Heavy Favorites in Legendary NY-Boston Rivalry on Sunday

Today, the Angels face the Mariners. Starting pitchers George Kirby and Tyler Anderson aim to rebound in a pivotal matchup. Seattle’s offense heats up.

Angels vs. Mariners Game Preview: Kirby Battles Anderson

Oakland's move to Sacramento has turned one of MLB's worst parks into a top hitters' paradise, engaging fans with higher game totals and more excitement.

Athletics Host Orioles at Hitter-Friendly Home Ballpark

LATEST VIDEOS

Mike Trout,Shane McClanahan,Jacob deGrom,Los Angeles Angels,Los Angeles  CA,American League,American League West,Tampa Bay Rays,Tampa Bay  FL,American League East,Texas Rangers,Texas  TX,MLB betting,AL Comeback Player of the Year,MLB futures betting,Shane McClanahan odds,Jacob deGrom comeback,Mike Trout betting,AL MVP race,MLB awards predictions,best MLB bets,MLB betting strategy,baseball odds,MLB comeback player,Tampa Bay Rays pitching,Texas Rangers rotation,Mike Trout injury,MLB season futures,Cy Young contenders,MLB player props,sports betting tips,best baseball bets,MLB futures market,Jacob deGrom odds,Shane McClanahan betting,Mike Trout odds,MLB betting picks,baseball betting strategy,MLB best odds,MLB player futures,Texas Rangers betting,Tampa Bay Rays odds,MLB award predictions,MLB betting guide,Jacob deGrom futures,best MLB futures bets,MLB comeback odds,Mike Trout AL MVP,best AL pitchers,Shane McClanahan comeback,MLB sportsbook odds,betting on MLB awards,MLB Awards Betting,MLB Futures

keywords

twitter:card

twitter:title

https://sg-images-bucket.nyc3.cdn.digitaloceanspaces.com/thumnbail-webp/article/2056542-1920x1080.webp?v=1749441742

twitter:image

thumbnail

google

The 2025 MLB season is about to get underway, meaning the futures board is rife with betting opportunities. Who wins MLB AL Comeback Player of the Year?

description

expires

robots

og:locale

og:site_name

og:type

og:title

og:description

og:image

og:image:type

og:image:width

og:image:height

og:image:secure_url

article:published_time

article:modified_time

Detroit Tigers Fantasy & Betting Outlook: Time to Move On from Javier Báez?

Red Sox vs. Yankees: Sunday Night Baseball Betting Insights

Can the Angels Capitalize on Yusei Kikuchi’s Two-Start Week?

Pete Crow-Armstrong Is Breaking Out—Here’s How to Profit

MLB Futures Betting: Who Will Finish with the Best Regular Season Record?

Luke Weaver Injury Opens Door for Devin Williams as Yankees’ Closer

Red Sox vs. Yankees: Sunday Night Baseball Same Game Parlay

Will Paul Goldschmidt of the New York Yankees Finish Top Seven in Fantasy Baseball Among 1B?

Cal Raleigh of the Seattle Mariners Breakout Season: Potential MVP Contender?

Impact of Corbin Burnes of the Arizona Diamondbacks Injury on Fantasy Baseball

SportsMillions: Pick'em, Blitz'em and Social Casino

Comment

Home

Articles

SportsGrid is your source for the best sports bets today. Watch SportsGrid for live sports news coverage, scores, odds, moneylines, sports betting tips & more.

sportsgrid.com

Ferrall Coast To Coast

College Football Today

NFL Pro Football Today

Bare Knuckle Fighting Main Event

The Early Line Live

SportsRage Tonight Live

NewsWire Live

The Bostonian Vs. The Book

Bare Knuckle Fighting Knuckle Up

MODUS Super Series Darts

Gametime Decisions Live

Fantasy Sports Today

The Smylie Kaufman Show

NHL Today

2025 NFL Draft Special

Ferrall Coast To Coast US Open Special

OUR SHOWS

Mets face Dollander at Coors Field, eyeing high scores with Alonso and Nimmo leading the charge. Donnie and Tom break down the matchup on Sunday afternoon.

Mets vs. Rockies Preview: Can New York Complete the Sweep?

LATEST SPORTSGRID VIDEOS

Wherever you are, SportsGrid can be there too. Here are all of the platforms and subscription services you can find us on and how to watch SportsGrid today.

Where to Watch SportsGrid | How to Watch SportsGrid | SportsGrid

Samsung TV Plus

Roku TV

FireTV

LG Channels

Vizio

Xiaomi

VIDAA

SportsGrid is free to watch on any of the following Connected TV’s

FREE ON MY TV

Amazon Prime Video

YouTube TV

FuboTV

Plex

Sling Tv

FreeCast

Local Now

Stremium

Rad TV

Free Live Sports

SportsGrid is free to watch on any of the following Streaming services

LIVE STREAMING SERVICES

Sirius XM

Sports.Tv

YouTube

Download the new SportsGrid app, watch on SportsGrid.com or our YouTube Channel

WEB/MOBILE

SportsGrid is free to watch on any of the following platforms

ALL PARTNERS

Wherever you are, SportsGrid can be there too. Here are all of the platforms and subscription services you can find us on:

WHERE TO WATCH SPORTSGRID

MORE ARTICLES

Sports Betting

Sportsbook Promos

Social Casinos